PDA

View Full Version : Anti-homeschooling bigots strike again



BigBadBrian
09-24-2004, 08:10 AM
Anti-homeschooling bigots strike again
Michelle Malkin


September 22, 2004


The public school establishment hates homeschoolers. They've smeared the movement as a conspiracy of conservative Christian zealots. They've scoffed at homeschooled kids as social pariahs. They've painted homeschooling parents as uneducated and negligent.

And now, under the guise of preparing students for a violent terrorist attack, educators in one public school district are casting homeschoolers in the role of bomb-detonating militants.

The story about a mock terrorism drill involving a local school district in the Muskegon Chronicle starts out innocently enough:

"Local school district transportation directors instigated the exercise because they wanted to test their abilities to respond to emergencies, said Tom Spoelman, transportation consultant for the Muskegon Area Intermediate School District. They eventually hooked up with Muskegon County Emergency Services, and planning for the event has been under way for about a year, Spoelman said.

"The exercise will test not only school transportation directors, but also the Muskegon County Emergency Operations Plan, which involves many agencies throughout the county.

"About 60 middle and high school students from Reeths-Puffer and Whitehall public schools will be part of the exercise, according to Kristin Tank, public information coordinator for the MAISD. Local law enforcement agencies, fire departments, human service agencies, transportation services and medical services will participate.

"Students from Muskegon Community College and Reeths-Puffer will assist in applying makeup to add to the reality of the gruesome scene. Between 200 and 300 people will observe the exercise, including school bus drivers, school administrators, emergency personnel and evaluators from agencies across the state who will provide feedback."

What's jaw-droppingly unbelievable is the next paragraph describing the attackers in the simulation:

"The exercise will simulate an attack by a fictitious radical group called Wackos Against Schools and Education who believe everyone should be homeschooled. Under the scenario, a bomb is placed on the bus and is detonated while the bus is traveling on Durham, causing the bus to land on its side and fill with smoke."

This is not a joke. A taxpayer-funded drill is using public school students to enforce anti-homeschooling bigotry under the guise of preparing for terrorism. Terrorism by whom? By Islamic jihadists who hijack planes and incinerate kids headed to Disneyworld. Islamic terrorists who take hundreds of children hostage in Beslan, force them to drink their own urine and shoot babies in the back. Islamic terrorists who groom toddlers as suicide bombers.

Our enemies are Islamic extremist murderers. Except if you happen to attend the Muskegon County, Mich., schools, where the menacing faces of terrorism belong to parents who make untold sacrifices to give their children the best education they know how by schooling them in the loving environment of their own homes.

I recall the Islamist-sympathizing admonition included in the National Education Association's touchy-feely, post-Sept. 11 curriculum: "Do not suggest that any group is responsible" for the terrorist attacks, one tip for parents and teachers urged. Unless, it should be amended, you can work an anti-homeschooling hate angle into the lesson.

When President Bush's education secretary, Rod Paige, likened the NEA in jest to a "terrorist organization," teachers' union officials and the media became completely unhinged. How dare he make such an odious comparison, they gasped. How dare he make light of the real terrorists, they fumed.

"I can tell you what my first response was: Scary. That's really frightening," said a special-education teacher in Bakersfield, Calif., to the Associated Press after Paige's remarks. "It's scary that you can't voice an opinion in this country without being called a terrorist. . . . I don't care if it was a joke or what it was, that was a totally inappropriate comment."

Paige was forced to apologize to teachers. What about the Muskegon County, Mich., school system? Will its public education militants apologize to homeschoolers for taking an intolerant swipe at their beliefs? Or will this politicized "Wackos Against Schools and Education" terror drill be coming to a classroom near you?

ODShowtime
09-24-2004, 10:29 AM
I saw Michelle Malkin on TV yesterday. Damn she's hot!

DrMaddVibe
09-24-2004, 10:36 AM
When will they face the facts that the public school system is in shambles. Discrediting home-schooling is a farce. The only activity that kids in public schools have excelled over home-schooled kids is in interacting with other kids. If your son or daughter has to put up with Eminem/Spears/Love/Dogg/Timberlakes of the world then they're not missing a damn thing.

How they test out with the knowledge and what they do with it is more important to me and besides people do learn at different levels. Standardized tests and dumbing down so everyone passes are a bad thing.

DrMaddVibe
09-24-2004, 10:37 AM
In regards to Malkin....

knuckleboner
09-24-2004, 10:49 AM
this isn't quite as bad as the hype mongerer author would have us believe.

1st off: not all our enemies are islamic fanatics. mcveigh comes to mind. eric rudolph. john allen muhammad (D.C. sniper. despite the name, not islamic-related).



that said, i'm happy to be against homeschooling. i really strongly doubt i'd outlaw it if i had the authority. (ok, i wouldn't outlaw it, that's certain. though i'd grumble about not doing so.)

but it doesn't do good for most kids.

i've only got antecdotal evidence. in college, i coached youth soccer. 1 team had 3 homeschooled kids. nicest, most polite kids i ever coached. and completely incapable of social interaction with their peers. they'd answer any question or comment asked of them by me or their teammates. but not once did they speak, otherwise. they just weren't comfortable.

i DO feel the parents homeschooled them because they thought it was what was best. and i respect that. i also respect that they tried to include other, social activities in their kids' lives.

one of the parents told one of our coaches that they homeschooled their son solely because they felt the public school wasn't challenging enough. i was too snot-nosed a college kid, myself, to jump in. but arrgggghh!!! then make your kid read books and such AFTER school. it's not ALL about the tests in grade school.

i'd rather 10 year olds had a chance to be normal 10 year olds. parochial school is fine if you feel the public schools aren't up to the task, educationally, or morally. really strict parochial schools are good. but let the kids have some level of normal social interaction.


(ok...knuckleboner's homeschooling rant is finished;D)

FORD
09-24-2004, 11:45 AM
There are probably legitimate reasons for homeschooling. If I lived in the district I went to school in, I wouldn't send my kids there.

On the other hand, there ARE a bunch of right wing MORONS out there who yank their kids out of school because "ain't nobody gonna teach my kids not to hate people god dammit". The majority of such people aren't the least bit qualified to teach their kids 3rd grade math, let alone an accurate version of history. And science?? Yeah, right. They might get as far as "what happens when you mix fuel oil and fertilizer", but that's probably the extent of the scientific knowledge in the trailer park.

BigBadBrian
09-24-2004, 12:19 PM
Originally posted by knuckleboner
this isn't quite as bad as the hype mongerer author would have us believe.

1st off: not all our enemies are islamic fanatics. mcveigh comes to mind. eric rudolph. john allen muhammad (D.C. sniper. despite the name, not islamic-related).



that said, i'm happy to be against homeschooling. i really strongly doubt i'd outlaw it if i had the authority. (ok, i wouldn't outlaw it, that's certain. though i'd grumble about not doing so.)

but it doesn't do good for most kids.

i've only got antecdotal evidence.

3 Kids? Gee, you can go be a pollster for the DNC. You are really reaching on this one KB. :gulp:

knuckleboner
09-24-2004, 12:48 PM
hey now...i acknowledged it as completely anectodotal:D



but i still stand behind my (admittingly limited) belief.

i respect parents who want to give their kids safer, better, more religious, etc. education. i just think that in most cases, homeschooling's not the best answer.


(that, plus, i sucked at spelling bees. so the nerd in me's probably holding a grudge;))

Ally_Kat
09-24-2004, 01:38 PM
my kids will never see the inside of a NYC public school.