metallica or megadeth

[Dave's Bitch]

hmmmmm,Metallica or Megadeth,James hetfield or Dave Mustaine.......what do you think?
i cant make my mind up,i meen old metallica rocked,but there new stuff is crap,megadeth pretty much all of there stuff is good,i dunno who i like better though

[Redballjets88]

megadeath is more psychotic than mettalica

[Dave's Bitch]

at the moment id have to say im a megadeth kinda girl,because i saw them live back in feb.wow they were amazing,i got right to the front and was just inches away from dave mustaine,arnt i a lucky girl

[Soul Reaper]

Easy, Megadeth!

NEXT!

[flappo]

they both suck

give me classic ac/dc any fucking day

:D

[Soul Reaper]

I liked early Metallica, but they got to caught it that Napster shit and their latest album sucked.

[julia]

megadeth all the way for me

[bueno bob]

I'll take them both up til, oh, 1988 or 1989...after that, they both got VERY old VERY quickly. I don't think either of them have done anything really outstanding in years and can't see any reason why either bands really keep on going, seriously...

[bueno bob]

Move this to the Music forum.

[UGS]

Dave Mustaine is a much better guitar player than Hetfield. James chugs (albeit fast and tight) power chords whereas Dave plays some awesome complex rhythms and still manages to sing over them. Dave's a better songwriter too, not all his songs sound the same. Also, Megadeth routinely has better lead guitarists than Kirk Hammet.

[Matt White]

The first 4 METALLICA cds alone put them at the TOP of the METAL MOUNTAIN.

[Rikk]

METALLICA...easily. And I really like their last album...better than anything since JUSTICE. The SNAKE album was just too polished in certain parts, though there are great songs.

[Panamark]

Originally posted by Matt White
The first 4 METALLICA cds alone put them at the TOP of the METAL MOUNTAIN.

Yeah, and how many of these were written by Megadeth ?
(Dave Mustaine)

Food for thought !

[Panamark]

Personally, I love both.

If I had to choose back in the 80's I would have said
Metallica.. Nowadays, Megadeth for sure...

They have always been really close in my book..

If you love really early Metallica, you cant deny Megadeth.

[EbDawson]

Originally posted by Panamark
Personally, I love both.

If I had to choose back in the 80's I would have said
Metallica.. Nowadays, Megadeth for sure...

They have always been really close in my book..

If you love really early Metallica, you cant deny Megadeth.

Where the Hell's your Aussie Megadeth review, Panamark?

[Mr Grimsdale]

Originally posted by Panamark
If I had to choose back in the 80's I would have said
Metallica.. Nowadays, Megadeth for sure...

Yep!

Whoever said Dave's a better guitarist is right, he plays much more complex stuff and is amazing live.

[WACF]

Megadeth is the better/more talented band.

I prefer Metallica though...IMO James is a far better singer than Dave.
I find Dave's voice gets tiring after awhile.

Their later stuff is not that terrible...you just have to seperate it from the earlier stuff.
They went from Metal Kings to one hell of a rock band.

[Soul Reaper]

Originally posted by UGS
Megadeth routinely has better lead guitarists than Kirk Hammet.

Marty Friedman owns Hammett

[nosuchluck]

they all own Hammett! i've heard that Nick Menza was a good guitarist too.

[Don Corleone]

Originally posted by Panamark
Yeah, and how many of these were written by Megadeth ?
(Dave Mustaine)

Food for thought !

The first 2 Metallica albums for sure where almost entirely written by Mustaine during his time with Metallica.

Has anyone ever seen the Cliff em All video? There's a pretty cool version of Whiplash on there (with Mustaine on lead)

[WACF]

Need to get that one yet.

Scammed this a while back...pretty cool to hear.

Metallica
Dave 'Em All (2000 Scary Cat liberated bootleg)

Source: bootleg CD-R > EAC WAV > FLAC

--------------------------------------
Disc 1: 38:34
--------------------------------------
Recorded January 1982 for 'Metal Massacre' Compilation LP*
01. Hit The Lights 04:24

Demos recorded March 1982
02. Let Loose 02:39
03. Killing Time 03:12

Ron McGovney Garage Rehearsals recorded March 1982
04. Hit The Lights 04:21
05. Sucking My Love 06:46
06. The Prince 05:00
07. Jump In THe Fire 04:25
08. Am I Evil? 07:44

-------------------------------------
Disc 2: 39:14
-------------------------------------

'No Life Til Leather' Demos Recorded on July 6, 1982 in Los Angeles, California, USA
01. Hit The Lights 04:17
02. The Mechanix 04:26
03. Motorbreath 03:16
04. Seek & Destroy 04:53
05. Metal Militia 05:12
06. Jump In The Fire 03:48
07. Phantom Lord 03:29

Demos recorded March 1983**
08. Whiplash 04:12
09. No Remorse 05:36

[Soul Reaper]

No Life Til Leather demos!

I've been wanting to hear them

[scottd1984]

Originally posted by Panamark
Personally, I love both.

If I had to choose back in the 80's I would have said
Metallica.. Nowadays, Megadeth for sure...

They have always been really close in my book..

If you love really early Metallica, you cant deny Megadeth.
I have to agree with you Panamark,Mustaine had a little lapse in judgement with "Risk" but otherwise he hasn't "sold out as much as Hetfield and Ulrich have

[Golden AWe]

Megadeth!!!

[Carmine]

METALLICA....although I enjoy Megadeth too.

[Atomic_Rob]

Megadeth, no doubt about it

[DrMaddVibe]

Originally posted by bueno bob
I'll take them both up til, oh, 1988 or 1989...after that, they both got VERY old VERY quickly. I don't think either of them have done anything really outstanding in years and can't see any reason why either bands really keep on going, seriously...


Bingo!

Although both are quite capable of releasing a song here or there that I like. "Fuel" was prolly a oler song from the good ol' Cliff Burton days!

[Mr Grimsdale]

Originally posted by scottd1984
I have to agree with you Panamark,Mustaine had a little lapse in judgement with "Risk" but otherwise he hasn't "sold out as much as Hetfield and Ulrich have

I actually think Risk was a pretty good record, just not exactly a good Megadeth record but there were some good tunes on there.

[Golden AWe]

Originally posted by Mr Grimsdale
I actually think Risk was a pretty good record, just not exactly a good Megadeth record but there were some good tunes on there.

Agreed.

I think it's a decent purchase, and you don't have pay much to get it...

[Last_Child]

Megadeth Becasue of Hangar 18...

but...AC/DC everytime!

[Soul Reaper]

complex riffs appeal to me more than chugging powerchords

[Dave's Bitch]

2 words


CRUSH 'EM

[canadiandlrgirl]

Originally posted by Sammy's Bitch
hmmmmm,Metallica or Megadeth,James hetfield or Dave Mustaine.......what do you think?
i cant make my mind up,i meen old metallica rocked,but there new stuff is crap,megadeth pretty much all of there stuff is good,i dunno who i like better though

Mustaine...hands down
Hetfield is a prick

[Warham]

Megadeth.
I own more of their albums.

[Dave's Bitch]

Originally posted by canadiandlrgirl
Mustaine...hands down
Hetfield is a prick


thats my opinion too now,but when i started the thread i LOVED Metallica.but there not even in my top 10 anymore.Dave Mustaine in my mind is the best metal singer ever and a totally amazing guitarist,and plus i think he's pretty hot,is that just me?
well thats beside the point

Megadeth All The Way

[mentalpancake]

Both bands were good for the first four albums and then sucked their way through the '90s...but Megadeth put out a great record last year and that alone makes me pick them.

[mentalpancake]

Originally posted by Sammy's Bitch
plus i think he's pretty hot,is that just me?
No, it's not just you.:D

[EbDawson]

Man, what's with Dave and these 15 year-old chicks? :D

[Dave's Bitch]

mmm he looks yummy on here

[MK5150]

Megadeth simply because I think they have better songs

[Dave's Bitch]

Megadeth's version of Battery is alot better than metallica's

[Jimmy Jingles]

I am a HUGE fan of early 'tallica. Ride totally floored me when it first came out. After that it all went

d
o
w
h
i
L
L

[Dave's Bitch]

i prefer basicaly any megadeth album to any metallica now,i have really gone off metallica

[Terry]

Metallica kicked ass through Master Of Puppets. And Justice For All was solid. The 'Black Album' was so-so. After that Metallica just didn't do it for me.

Was never a huge fan of Megadeth, although I concede that Dave is more interesting to me than Kirk or James.

[mentalpancake]

Originally posted by EbDawson
Man, what's with Dave and these 15 year-old chicks? :D
It's just that the 15 year old chicks have good taste.:D

[Dave's Bitch]

Originally posted by mentalpancake
It's just that the 15 year old chicks have good taste.:D

yup :)

[FasterPussycat]

Tough one... Metallica by a narrow margin!!!

[fret_buzz_blues]

Originally posted by mentalpancake
It's just that the 15 year old chicks have good taste.:D
You said that right. So that makes...three of us?
Oh, and I pick Megadeth. I find them to be a lot better.

[zeronumber]

Metallica by a long shot.

claim whatever you want, about polotics, selling out, whatever...
Metallica kicks your momma's ass.

I saw them live back in '03 in the Summer Sanitarium tour, and they brought Giant stadium to the fucking ground with thier performance.

Don't get me wrong, Dave and his attempt at a rival band is good...but seriously, I never heard, or seen anything by megadeth that would make me think they are a better band.

Hell...

The only thing megadeth has over metallica is the last albulms via comparasion...

And that's only because metallica chose not to add guitar solos, and went for a garage band sound.

[Dave's Bitch]

i suggest you go buy rust in peace and countdown to extinction and then try and say

[Soul Reaper]

i only have Rust In Peace. i heard it went downhill after that

[Dave's Bitch]

it went downhill after countdown

[Dave's Bitch]

Originally posted by FasterPussycat
Tough one... Metallica by a narrow margin!!!


Shut up no way

[Unchainme]

hey at lest Mustaine doesn't sue his Fans over Napster, Fuck Metallica, Megadeth rules.

[Dave's Bitch]

Originally posted by Unchainme
hey at lest Mustaine doesn't sue his Fans over Napster, Fuck Metallica, Megadeth rules.

Fuck Yea

Megadeth Rules

[FasterPussycat]

Yeh, but you have to judge them on musical merit as well...and I like metallica better!!

[VonHalen]

MEGADETH, nuff said

[thome]

I never fully got into either i like both bands music for speed metal

both are the tops.

I am not so turned on by the lack of individual notes i am ignorant
of the proper way of saying that just too fast and aggressive.

I had just started getting down w metalica years ago when i read or saw something about Mustain really being the" Inventor creator "
of this type of music and Metalica getting all the Glory and Money
and jerking Mustain around i was turned off at that moment.

Reminded me of anouther rip off that made a fortune Van Hagar.

[Dave's Bitch]

i heard a Megadeth version of for whom the bell tolls today and it was better than the Metallica version

[theicecreamman]

Megadeth hands down

[Dirty Duck]

For my boy Paul in Callicoon (who I know will agree) I'm gonna say

MEGAGETH

Let's not forget what Lars said back when they changed they're image:
Heavy metal is dead.In my book...so are they. Long live metal and rock!!!!

[Dave's Bitch]

Originally posted by Dirty Duck
For my boy Paul in Callicoon (who I know will agree) I'm gonna say

MEGAGETH



Megageth?

[Shaun Ponsonby]

Ah, you're Dave's Bitch again.

Who did it for you?

[Dave's Bitch]

Originally posted by Shaun Ponsonby
Ah, you're Dave's Bitch again.

Who did it for you?


:) Mezro did it for me


Mezro Rules

[Shaun Ponsonby]

Mezro is the greatest of all the webmasters.

[Dave's Bitch]

ya Mezro is the man

[Soul Reaper]

I'm the greatest of all webmasterbators.

[Dave's Bitch]

Originally posted by Soul Reaper
I'm the greatest of all webmasterbators.


hehe :D

[Soul Reaper]

:D :D :D :D

[Shaun Ponsonby]

Originally posted by Soul Reaper
I'm the greatest of all webmasterbators.

Hehehehehehehehehe!

You said "all".

[Soul Reaper]

all is a mighty word indeed, Sir Shaun

[Dirty Duck]

sorry..typing way too fast here...


MEGADETH!!!!!!!

[Dave's Bitch]

Originally posted by Dirty Duck
sorry..typing way too fast here...


MEGADETH!!!!!!!

lol :)

[Shaun Ponsonby]

Originally posted by Soul Reaper
all is a mighty word indeed, Sir Shaun

INDEED it is, Mighty Reap