Humans Being and DLR

[hollywood5150]

We all seem to often talk about the great music that CVH made with ROTH.....

And Van Hagars lack of decent music..........BUT what about Humans Being? does that song not kick ass?

What if ROTH sang it?

[ALinChainz]

What if this wasn't in the sports forum?

Moving to main.

[hollywood5150]

dont know how...........sorry.............still new at this stuff

[ALinChainz]

Originally posted by hollywood5150
dont know how...........sorry.............still new at this stuff

No problem.

[Terry]

So.....basically Van Hagar put out a couple tracks that didn't totally suck on an instrumental level, is that the point?

Far as 'what if' and Dave singing over Van Hagar music, how are you gonna ever know if it would have sounded 'better' if Dave sang over it? Dave's not gonna write lyrics like that to begin with, and he doesn't phrase his singing like Hagar.

[Nickdfresh]

What if we didn't already a recent thread on this in the VH/DLR SONGS Forum?

http://www.rotharmy.com/forums/showthread.php?s=&threadid=19867

http://www.rotharmy.com/forums/showthread.php?s=&threadid=22252

[Mezro]

Originally posted by Nickdfresh
What if we didn't already a recent thread on this in the VH/DLR SONGS Forum?

What if hollywood5150 never posted again?

Mezro...the world would be a better place...

[hollywood5150]

I am talking SPECIFICALY ABOUT HUMANS BEINGS

GOOD OR NOT GOOD???

WHAT IF ROTH SANG IT OR A SONG LIKE IT???

how do you think it would sound if ROTH sang a decent heavy tune like that???

besides i made a mistake...........this thread wasnt supposed to be here

SORRY...........

[Vinnie Velvet]

First off, if Roth was given the MUSIC to Humans Being, it would come out to be quite different than Van Hagar's version.

Dave would never write a chorus that would say "Shine On, Shine On.."

[hollywood5150]

I agree...........but technically speaking.................what do you people think of the tune.........

how would it SOUND IF ROTH SANG SOMETHING LIKE THAT???

[DR CHIP]

Humans Being is one of the better Van Hagar songs..."better" doesn't mean great, just means better than let's say "Love comes walking in" -get the point?

The problem with your question as I see it is this: Dave didn't take a packaged piece of music like Sammy does and add lyrics, Dave changed stuff around and helped structure songs...

The reason VH was SO great was because of Dave...

Ed may have been a great guitar player at one time, but Dave is the reason that songs were great...

No other way to explain the abysmal shit that Van Hagar spewed upon the rock world....

So the twofold answer to your question: (1) Does "Humans Being" kick ass? Yes, if it is compared to "Message in a bottle". Absolutely not when compared to the 6 pack.

(2) What would it have sounded like if Dave sang it? Not like it sounded with Sammy...

Peace

[canadiandlrgirl]

that song sux...sounds like spammy is constipated in that song

[hollywood5150]

thank you Dr Chip.............that is the type of answer i was looking for.

I was not trying to start shit with anyone......... OR state that Van Hagar was good or better than CVH

CVH is the reason I like rock and roll, CVH is the reason for alot of things.......

however they are still my fave choice...... look at the CVH/EVH - KISS
forum threads.........

[tjvhou812]

where's the pisser...i gotta take a leak

[DLR7884]

That song sucks.

This thread sucks.

DLR7884
Any questions?