If Dave were the judge of American Idol

[DLR7884]

Originally posted by BrownSound1
Are you sure about that?

I remember reading something on Yahoo.com this summer about Dave possibly being a guest judge.

I sure as fuck hope that was just a rumor.

DLR7884
Please just be a rumor.

[monkeythe]

Dave's music has already been featured on American Idol. They had the final last year between the fat guy and the gay guy (Reuben vs Clay, whoops meant to say Sammy & Gary) trying to sing CVH and everyone lost.

Seriously, if they had a Dave night the singers couldn't do a worse injustice to the songs than Sam & GAry did. And it would be interesting to hear CVH sung by a woman (Gary don't count).

[Northern Girl]

I really hope he doesn't do it. That would be the only thing that would get me to watch it though. Gak!

[Last_Child]

Idol Suck!



Especially the Norwegian version..

[spmusicplyr]

If i were dave i'd tell the fine female contestants that if they wanna win they'd better meet me out back 15minutes before their audition!

[Shaun Ponsonby]

Part of me wants him to go on, the other half doesn't. I don't want him to sink so low like Kenny Loggins and Gene Simmons-but you don't see Dave on TV that often in the UK, so I would love to tune in to ITV2 one Sunday morning and see him upstaging everybody with his unique brand of Rothisms.