My Dream Van Halen Lineup

[Unchainme]

Since Al is a dick, and Mike is Sam's Boyfriend, I thought what If Ed and The Diamond One still wanted tour, Heres My Dream Van Halen
Lead Singer- Diamond David Lee Roth
Guitar- Ed
Bass- Billy Sheehan
Drums- Dave Grohl (He did awesome with His Metal project Probot, and he probaly was obssesed with Van Halen when he was a kid, so why not)

Your Thoughts?

[jero]

Although it sounds great on paper, I don't think they can make it sound like CVH!

[Carmine]

Originally posted by jero
Although it sounds great on paper, I don't think they can make it sound like CVH!

ditto...

[moose]

Great choices, but just not CVH.

[DlocRoth]

Yep...Sheehan is too good.

[franksters]

Dave doesn't need any of the sisters anymore...

he should just keep on doin what he does and that's it, add some of the solo stuff and I'll be happy.

do you seriously think that if Dave reunite with vh he will perform spammy era kindy garden rock ballad?????

[bueno bob]

No

[Carmine]

Originally posted by franksters


do you seriously think that if Dave reunite with vh he will perform spammy era kindy garden rock ballad?????

NO!NO! NO!

[bueno bob]

Besides...for a new bassist, I'd pick John Alderete...

[Carmine]

Originally posted by bueno bob
Besides...for a new bassist, I'd pick John Alderete...

Les Claypool..."My name is MUD"....

[bueno bob]

Originally posted by Carmine Raguzza.
Les Claypool..."My name is MUD"....

...so I kissed him upside his cranium with an aluminum baseball bat, my name is mud...

Claypool is a great funk bassist, for sure...but I honestly feel John's chops are virtually second to none, Claypool, Sheehan, Coven...John's just an outstandingly good bassist...his instructional shit has blown my fuckin' mind more than anything else recently...amazing...

[Dave's Bitch]

wouldnt be the same without alex and mike....

[bueno bob]

But it could be better!

Truth, it wouldn't be CVH at all.

Hey Carmine, here's some trivia for ya - between 1983 and 1984, Les Claypool engineered two or three albums for a young, hot new guitarist - any guesses who it was?

[Carmine]

Originally posted by bueno bob
...so I kissed him upside his cranium with an aluminum baseball bat, my name is mud...

Claypool is a great funk bassist, for sure...but I honestly feel John's chops are virtually second to none, Claypool, Sheehan, Coven...John's just an outstandingly good bassist...his instructional shit has blown my fuckin' mind more than anything else recently...amazing...

Did you know Claypool tried out for Metallica after Cliff Burton died...

...It appears not to have gone well...

[bueno bob]

Originally posted by Carmine Raguzza.
Did you know Claypool tried out for Metallica after Cliff Burton died...

...It appears not to have gone well...

Yeah, Les said that, uh...he was the "entirely wrong guy" for the position