pro Roth /VH duscussion on Stern this morning

[lafours]

Vh and the RRHOF was brought up this morning and Fred, Robin , and Artie all said that if VH called it quits in 1985 they would still be worthy of the Rock and Roll Halll of Fame... Artie said something to the effect of if they started as a new band in 1985 with Hagar there is no way they would be there... Stern said they were popular with Sammy though...only to have Robin point out that Sammy walked into a hugely popular band that was built on the Dave years...

[rocket]

More honesty from the Stern show.

[jgdrag]

Yes, that is something no hagar fan would admit. Van Halen were on top when Dave left.

[Antman]

Hagar basically admitted this recently when interviewed about the RRHOF. He still doesn't deserve the honor IMO.

[Nickdfresh]

Originally posted by jgdrag
Yes, that is something no hagar fan would admit. Van Halen were on top when Dave left.

Not true at all. Only about .0001% of the Van Halen fan community, even those that like Van Hagar, would claim that anything Van Hagar did was BETTER than Classic Van Halen. And most of those that would are usually very late 20-somethings to early 30-somethings that heard Van Hagar first and have some gay sentimental attachment to them...

[PlexiBrown]

Stern said they were popular with Sammy though...only to have Robin point out that Sammy walked into a hugely popular band that was built on the Dave years...

Hey...Robin ripped off my post from yesterday.

[Terry]

Originally posted by Nickdfresh
Not true at all. Only about .0001% of the Van Halen fan community, even those that like Van Hagar, would claim that anything Van Hagar did was BETTER than Classic Van Halen. And most of those that would are usually very late 20-somethings to early 30-somethings that heard Van Hagar first and have some gay sentimental attachment to them...

Without a doubt. Anyone who even tried to make a case that Van Halen weren't already hugely successful by the time Roth bailed, and only were AFTER Hagar joined, is just clearly not in command of the facts.

[jgdrag]

You can't tell them that though
Fuckin blind mice

[Brett]

Since when does anyone listen to what the what the fuck Robin thinks? Or fat Artie?

Yes it's true about VH did enough to get in by 1985, but when it comes to music, EVERYONE on that show is a fucking dumbass.

Howard, Gary, and Artie have probably the worst musical taste ever.

[Brett]

Originally posted by jgdrag
Yes, that is something no hagar fan would admit. Van Halen were on top when Dave left.

There is not one Van Halen fan on the planet that wouldn't say VH wasn't on top of when Dave left. You find me one person who thinks VH was at the bottom of the music world in 1984, then you've found the dumbest person on earth.

[jgdrag]

You Brett are far away an original who actually gives credit where it is deserved, however do not fool yourself in thinking everyone who enjoys Van Hagar would give respect to CVH.

[jhale667]

I'm surprised Nickdfresh hasn't posted the file yet (hint, hint) ....

Seriously, anybody got it?

[azcrdnal]

Originally posted by Brett
Since when does anyone listen to what the what the fuck Robin thinks? Or fat Artie?

Yes it's true about VH did enough to get in by 1985, but when it comes to music, EVERYONE on that show is a fucking dumbass.

Howard, Gary, and Artie have probably the worst musical taste ever.

and you are a sammy fan and you drive a broken down pinto stern shits on you believe me.

[Tiki-Tom]

Stern and his crew know the real deal. They have been in Dave's corner for years. This is no surprise

[azcrdnal]

Originally posted by Tiki-Tom
Stern and his crew know the real deal. They have been in Dave's corner for years. This is no surprise

bretts been in sams corner for years.

[bantonelli]

Originally posted by lafours
...only to have Robin point out that Sammy walked into a hugely popular band that was built on the Dave years...

DEAD ON!

[Tiki-Tom]

Originally posted by azcrdnal
bretts been in sams corner for years.

I stand corrected, Most (the ones that count) have been in dave's corner.