Originally Posted by
Terry
How many CVH tunes did Hagar actually sing on a regular basis when Van Hagar was a working band (as opposed to the one-off 2004 reunion)?
Let's see:
Jump
Ain't Talking About Love
Panama
I think possibly You Really Got Me on the 1988/1989 tour. I seem to remember hearing a bootleg of Van Halen in Japan 1989 where they did YRGM. Dunno if they did it on the Monsters of Rock stateside tour or not.
It's not like Sammy took the approach Gary Cherone did on the VHIII tour, where all of these CVH tunes other than the above-mentioned CVH greatest hits standards were dusted off and given an airing. Partly because Sam had a fair amount of solo Hagar tunes to draw upon prior to joining Van Halen, and partly because Hagar never WANTED any comparisons between what he was doing with Van Halen and what Dave did. And if I were Hagar in that situation, honestly I wouldn't want to go onstage and sing a bunch of Roth tunes, either.
Sammy sounded just as bad doing the CVH tunes he DID bother doing as Roth undoubtedly would have singing Van Hagar tunes. Really, it comes down to attitude and approach rather than vocal abilities. Frankly, when Hagar's in Van Halen I don't want to hear him singing Roth-era stuff any more than I'd want to hear Roth doing his take on a Sam Halen tune.
I mean. it seems fairly obvious to say that those parts of the Van Halen fanbase hoping a reunion with Roth would happen weren't basing that on the pretext that "it would be great to have Dave back in the band because I always wondered how he would sound singing Why Can't This Be Love".