Annual Rock Hall Nominee Shit Show thread

[Warham]

I'm not a HUGE fan by any measure...but I think it's a joke that Idol hasn't been nominated. He's a huge figure, was a massive star and has influenced a ton of people.

I love the guy. There was a time in the 90s when I pretty much took my fashion cues from him, including the hair.

[Seshmeister]

I'm not a HUGE fan by any measure...but I think it's a joke that Idol hasn't been nominated. He's a huge figure, was a massive star and has influenced a ton of people.

There was a point I remember and I did check it at the time although it's probably not true any more, where Billy Idol had more Best Of albums out than albums which is pretty amazing.

[Warham]

Na, he had Vital Idol that was 1985 and re-released in 1987. “Mony, Mony” hit #1 that year.
Best Of was 1988 and Europe only
Best Of (different version) in 2001. Had “Don’t You Forget About Me” cover.
Idolize Yourself was 2008. Had two new songs.

He’s had 7 studio albums, a Christmas album, and several EPs.

[Seshmeister]

O'Connor is an obvious make-up nomination and now that she's dead they don't have to deal with her issues. And whoever inducts her will probably play a song that isn't even hers!

To be fair she did have more than one song but you guys wouldn't know that because she was completely and utterly cancelled in the US for accusing the catholic church of having a pedophile problem 10 years before it was proved.

She was also a bit fucking crazy but that's also why she did it.

[Seshmeister]

Na, he had Vital Idol that was 1985 and re-released in 1987. “Mony, Mony” hit #1 that year.
Best Of was 1988 and Europe only
Best Of in 2001. Had “Don’t You Forget About Me” cover.
Idolize Yourself was 2008. Had two new songs.

He’s had 7 studio albums, a Christmas album, and several EPs.

Oh don't make me do this it's too much work.

I think it was in the early 1990s but there was a time. I'll maybe take the time to check. Of course it could be a false memory but I don't think so.

[Seshmeister]

There we go -

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Billy_Idol_discography

At the moment it's 7-7.

[Warham]

He had a span between 1993 and 2005 where he really didn’t do much.

The actual career he’s had speaks for itself. Chart success (four top ten hits), one of the early MTV icons, had platinum albums and had always been one of the coolest looking rock stars ever. He also has done the best cover of “Jump” by anyone.

[Seshmeister]

I'm not knocking him I like his best work and have covered it at various times in bands. Nothing wrong with quality over quantity.

[Warham]

I like how he emphasized having songs with good basslines and didn’t think it was a sin to make his material dance friendly. He knew where he could pick up an audience when he moved to NY. I think that’s where he differed from many of his punk contemporaries, especially after he went solo after Generation X.

[Seshmeister]

He could also write a good song unlike most of his punk contemporaries.

[Warham]

Sorry I turned this into an Idol thread. I don’t really talk about him as much as I would like.

[Seshmeister]

This thread appears every year and everyone gets annoyed - I think the problem is that they need to change the name to the 'Modern Music Hall of Fame'.

Most of it isn't Rock (N Roll) and hasn't been for a long time...

[Warham]

I do think groups like Public Enemy and NWA should be in a Hall of Fame. I’m just not sure it should be the RRHOF. But that bridge has already been crossed.

[Seshmeister]

I think the Grammys are actually even worse although for some reason seem to be more respected.

Beyoncé and Jay-Z have won 56 Grammys between them.

Queen, Guns N' Roses, Abba, Van Halen and The Who have none. Zero. Zilch.

[Warham]

The Grammys have been a joke since the 60s. “Good Vibrations” didn’t win for 1966 recording of the year even though it’s the greatest #1 single of all-time.