Led Zep To Reform?

[Shaun Ponsonby]

No, 'taint gonna happen, I just thought I'd post the rumour to get everyone's hopes up.

[Panamark]

At least they did actually do the reunion thing for the fans...

[Matt White]

Originally posted by Rikk
I personally thought WALKING INTO CLARKSDALE was a great album. I really loved Page's playing on that and the two worked very well together again. I would love a follow-up.

I, too, however, like PLANT's new album.

BWAHAHAHAHA!!!

I think we're the only two people alive who thought WALKING INTO CLARKSDALE was Killer Rikk!!!

Sounded GRATE live!!!

I think I'll listen to it on my way to work!

[Rikk]

Originally posted by Matt White
BWAHAHAHAHA!!!

I think we're the only two people alive who thought WALKING INTO CLARKSDALE was Killer Rikk!!!

Sounded GRATE live!!!

I think I'll listen to it on my way to work!

Been listening to it a lot this week. Also been playing PLANT's new album today.

And you're right...the stuff was great live. What a tour!

MOST HIGH is a classic. Some would shoot me for this...but I'd put it up there with IN THE EVENING and TEN YEARS GONE.

[Terry]

Have dug Plant's solo stuff. The Plant and Page Un-Ledded thing kinda sucked, as did Walking Into Clarksdale.

I mean, even if Jason Bonham and JPJ did participate, and LZ did 'reunite', what would be the point? Plant's voice isn't totally shot, but he wouldn't be able to pull off a lot of the Zep stuff in the original key. The two documented times 'Led Zep' tried to get back together post-1980 were pretty lame, and I wasn't all that impressed with the 1995 jam at the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame.

The Zep DVD released a couple years back was great. If Zep wanna do something, dig up the rest of the footage from Knebworth, Earls Court and find some 1977 tour stuff - throw that shit on another DVD for us. That'd excite me more than watching Plant, Page, Jason B and JPJ take a shot at competing against a legacy they have no chance in hell of matching.

[Antman]

I don't think it will ever happen but if it does Jason Bonham would be the only acceptable replacement. Besides, why would Jason Bonham give up his Foreigner gig? Plus John Paul Jones is still pissed at Plant.

[ben halen]

Originally posted by Rikk
Been listening to it a lot this week. Also been playing PLANT's new album today.

And you're right...the stuff was great live. What a tour!

MOST HIGH is a classic. Some would shoot me for this...but I'd put it up there with IN THE EVENING and TEN YEARS GONE.

No comment.

[TEMPLEMAN]

The chick drummer from White Stripes would be the first choice to play drums for Zep ofcourse.

FUCK THAT!!!!!!!!!!!!

[tydhurst]

Originally posted by TEMPLEMAN
The chick drummer from White Stripes would be the first choice to play drums for Zep ofcourse.

FUCK THAT!!!!!!!!!!!!

Award for the least funny Recruit goes to...

THIS GUY!

[Vinnie Velvet]

A full blown Zep reunion will never happen.

And as someone said earlier --three words: John Henry Bonham.

They've done one-off performances in the past (Live Aid, Atlantic Records anniversary show, etc) and Page and Plant have toured by themselves, but I think you'll never see a LED ZEPPELIN reunion tour.

But the rumours will always be around.

[ODShowtime]

Originally posted by Matt White
BWAHAHAHAHA!!!

I think we're the only two people alive who thought WALKING INTO CLARKSDALE was Killer Rikk!!!

Sounded GRATE live!!!

I think I'll listen to it on my way to work!

I don't have the album, but a couple of those tunes SMOKED live. Most High was like the Kashmir/When the Levee Breaks sequel.

[DLR_EngineRoom]

Originally posted by guitarboy5150
that would be awesome if they did but it wouldnt be lz w/o bonham...they should call it something else

NOPE.....call it Led Zeppelin 'cause they NEED to get Bonzo's son Jason on the skins....that guy knows his dad's stuff better than anyone in the world.....I don't think Bonzo would mind his own son replacing him....

[classicdude]

Might be nice to see them reunited, but I doubt it would ever happen. I think AC/DC is probably the most successful act to play on without an original member. Journey isn't the same without Steve Perry. I don't think of the current tour as a Queen tour since Freddie Mercury is gone.

[Shaun Ponsonby]

Originally posted by classicdude
I don't think of the current tour as a Queen tour since Freddie Mercury is gone.

That's why its called Queen + Paul Rodgers, and not just Queen.

Seriously, though, I'm the biggest Freddie fan in the world (maybe I'm exaggerating a bit), and I have to say that Paul Rodgers is doing an excellent job, and it's good to see Brian and Roger playing together again. They needed to call it Queen so as they could get people interested, they couldn't call it May Taylor and Rodgers, because it doesn't have a ring to it, Queen + Paul Rodgers tells you everything you need to know. Its members of Queen, and Paul Rodgers. Sorry, I'm ranting again. I love a good rant!

Brian himself said "Its not the Queen you saw 20 years ago, its a very different animal".

[Shaun Ponsonby]

Originally posted by classicdude
I think AC/DC is probably the most successful act to play on without an original member.

YES
DEEP PURPLE
GENESIS
RAINBOW
WHITESNAKE
PINK FLOYD
MOTORHEAD

All did their best business without original members.