If this is your first visit to the Roth Army, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.
Originally posted by Cathedral Yeah, lol, i realized through the night that i had Hezbollah and Hamas confused.
My bad, but it doesn't change my opinion about nukes, and i agree 100% with you that NOBODY needs nukes.
Don't feel too bad about your gaff. You may have intended to be using Hamas and Palestine as your example but your accidental use of Hezbollah governing brings up one of the issues that makes this conflict far from simple.
Hezbollah is not just a terrorist organization, they are also democratically elected members of the Lebanese government (14 elected members, I do believe). Hezbollah do represent a segment of the Lebanese population and they are far from secretive. They are also almost entirely funded by the Syrians and the Iranians. This combination and the inability of the ruling Lebanese government to control the actions of Hezbollah on their soil has certainly added fuel to the Israeli position.
It does seem that the Israeli reaction to a simple military action (the attack on the Israeli tank company and the kidnapping of Israeli soldiers) has been far from showing reasonable restraint but as I've pointed out the situation is far from simple.
The majority of all civilians caught in the midst of military action are essentially innocents so FORD and friends who continue to use this against Israel are really just following the media's lead. Using the strife of innocent people to make a case against any military action is almost childish. It overly simplifies very complicated situations and makes choosing sides black and white. Israel kills women and children, Hezbollah attacks the Israel military. Cut and dry right? Israel is the bad guy. Israel has decided that Lebanon is incapable of controlling Hezbollah and the Lebanese people, unfortunately, are going to pay a heavy price. The Lebanese people, however, had their choice to completely distance themselves from Hezbollah and chose instead to include them in their government.
Are the innocents completely innocent? Lets hope Syria and Iran stay out of direct action long enough for diplomacy to have a chance to end what is so far a small conflict. And yes, before it's mentioned, let's hope Israel doesn't move against Syria at the same time.
Originally posted by m_dixon1984 Don't feel too bad about your gaff. You may have intended to be using Hamas and Palestine as your example but your accidental use of Hezbollah governing brings up one of the issues that makes this conflict far from simple.
Hezbollah is not just a terrorist organization, they are also democratically elected members of the Lebanese government (14 elected members, I do believe). Hezbollah do represent a segment of the Lebanese population and they are far from secretive. They are also almost entirely funded by the Syrians and the Iranians. This combination and the inability of the ruling Lebanese government to control the actions of Hezbollah on their soil has certainly added fuel to the Israeli position.
It does seem that the Israeli reaction to a simple military action (the attack on the Israeli tank company and the kidnapping of Israeli soldiers) has been far from showing reasonable restraint but as I've pointed out the situation is far from simple.
The majority of all civilians caught in the midst of military action are essentially innocents so FORD and friends who continue to use this against Israel are really just following the media's lead. Using the strife of innocent people to make a case against any military action is almost childish. It overly simplifies very complicated situations and makes choosing sides black and white. Israel kills women and children, Hezbollah attacks the Israel military. Cut and dry right? Israel is the bad guy. Israel has decided that Lebanon is incapable of controlling Hezbollah and the Lebanese people, unfortunately, are going to pay a heavy price. The Lebanese people, however, had their choice to completely distance themselves from Hezbollah and chose instead to include them in their government.
Are the innocents completely innocent? Lets hope Syria and Iran stay out of direct action long enough for diplomacy to have a chance to end what is so far a small conflict. And yes, before it's mentioned, let's hope Israel doesn't move against Syria at the same time.
M
Now THIS is how you post at the army, HoooAhhhhh!
So, i really wasn't wrong, just a bit twisted with my details.
I'm trying to pay attention but, so far this year has kept my mind working double overtime.
I've been asking people all day long what they think started all of this and did not get any two answers that were the same....I feel like i live in Babylon and everyone is speaking a different language.
What i did learn is that conservatives support Israel and liberals don't.
lounge you may say im like a 6th grader but with the way you act you sound like a 3rd grader...be more like ford and learn how to have a decent debate over ideas
R.I.P Van Halen 1978-1984
hopefully God will ressurect you
"i wont be messing with you in future.the fearsome redballjets88 for fear of you owning me some more" Axl S
Originally posted by Cathedral Now THIS is how you post at the army, HoooAhhhhh!
So, i really wasn't wrong, just a bit twisted with my details.
I'm trying to pay attention but, so far this year has kept my mind working double overtime.
I've been asking people all day long what they think started all of this and did not get any two answers that were the same....I feel like i live in Babylon and everyone is speaking a different language.
What i did learn is that conservatives support Israel and liberals don't.
It 's a good thing I don't consider myself either a conservative or a liberal. I'm far too skeptical to base my opinion on the position of either. I'm too skeptical of most of what is being said about the cause and effect of the middle-eastern situation. It's fucked up. The actions of both sides are fucked up. The responses just as fucked up. The end result is going to be one fucked region with a badly fucked up population. Getting involved is pretty fucked up. Not getting involved well that's fucked up to. Innocent people dying...damned fucked up. Nukes even having to be discussed...hella fucked up. Limiting yourself ideologically to a single point of view or perspective...myopically fucked up.
Originally posted by Cathedral Now THIS is how you post at the army, HoooAhhhhh!
So, i really wasn't wrong, just a bit twisted with my details.
I'm trying to pay attention but, so far this year has kept my mind working double overtime.
I've been asking people all day long what they think started all of this and did not get any two answers that were the same....I feel like i live in Babylon and everyone is speaking a different language.
What i did learn is that conservatives support Israel and liberals don't.
It's true. Rockets are always getting fired into Israel targeting basically anything in it's path. Suicide bombers are always attacking buses and cafes where innocent people go into do their own business. Israel has been battling their hostile neighbours for almost 6 years now. I'm hoping that soon there will be a ceasefire and a solution to all this. All Lebanon has to do is release the soldiers unharmed and reconstruction can begin in Lebanon. With the G8 Summit taking place,
world leaders are looking at both sides and are willing to ask both to negotiate. It sucks to see all the Israel bashing going on here, but I guess everyone is entitled to their own opinion. It's sad to see places get bombed and people getting killed, but this has to stop.
That's why it's great that we have a Conservative minority government here. Liberals may have a say in certain things, but the Cons are the ones basically running the show now.
What i did learn is that conservatives support Israel and liberals don't.
That's a ridiculous generalization.
Pat Buchanan is a true conservative. His level of support for Israel is so low that he's been called "anti-semite" more than once. And in more recent years, he's certainly been no fan of the PNAC agenda.
I am a Liberal. I support the existence of the state of Israel. I also support the right of the Palestinian people to have their own state. Israel has the same right to self defense as any other nation, within reason.
Bombing the living shit out of Lebanon, killing children and Canadian nationals, and fucking up infrastructure (in order to secure new Haliburton contracts) is NOT a reasonable response to the "kidnapping" of two Israeli soldiers, who BTW were NOT within Israeli borders when they were captured. (Bet the Jerusalem Likud Post forgot to mention that part, didn't they?)
No nation has the right to live by different rules than anybody else. And I will NEVER support such lawless arrogance. Not from the Likud. Not from the BCE. Not from anybody.
"If the American people had ever known the truth about what we (the BCE) have done to this nation, we would be chased down in the streets and lynched." - Poppy Bush, 1992
Originally posted by RuzDNailz That's why it's great that we have a Conservative minority government here. Liberals may have a say in certain things, but the Cons are the ones basically running the show now.
So you think it's a GOOD thing that Little Stevie Wonderbush could care less that CANADIANS have been murdered by these lawless fascists?
"If the American people had ever known the truth about what we (the BCE) have done to this nation, we would be chased down in the streets and lynched." - Poppy Bush, 1992
Comment