Oh, I absolutely agree. There's ample anecdotal evidence that Poe suffered some sort of mental shock around his early 20s, though we'll probably never know EXACTLY what happened.
Now, Poe is considered by many a horror writer first & foremost, as you'll find if you see any bound collection of his works, or any adaptation of his stories. He's always sold as the Master of Horror. But I agree that is limiting the whole body of work of the man.
Even his more supernatural stories were never straightforward stock horror. There was always the underlying whispers of absolute madness on his characters. And suer enough, the monsters were always human. Even in stories with some form of ghosts in them.
As for Lovecraft, the biggest reason I or anyone else associate him with Poe is not for his own writing, but rather the fact that Lovecraft himself kept going on & on about Poe, so much that you cannot speak of Lovecraft without bringing Poe into the discussion, though you can certainly completely dismiss Lovecraft when talking about Poe.

Brilliant.
I tip my hat off to you, madam.
Now, Poe is considered by many a horror writer first & foremost, as you'll find if you see any bound collection of his works, or any adaptation of his stories. He's always sold as the Master of Horror. But I agree that is limiting the whole body of work of the man.
Even his more supernatural stories were never straightforward stock horror. There was always the underlying whispers of absolute madness on his characters. And suer enough, the monsters were always human. Even in stories with some form of ghosts in them.
As for Lovecraft, the biggest reason I or anyone else associate him with Poe is not for his own writing, but rather the fact that Lovecraft himself kept going on & on about Poe, so much that you cannot speak of Lovecraft without bringing Poe into the discussion, though you can certainly completely dismiss Lovecraft when talking about Poe.

Brilliant.
I tip my hat off to you, madam.

Comment