What band members should make up VAN HALEN???

[TMR]

If you could merge the two bands of David Lee Roth, who would be in the future lineup of Van Halen.


David Lee Roth
Steve Vai
Billy Sheehan
Eddie Van Halen
Greg Bissonette

Ushers would be Alex Van Halen and Michael Anthony!!

Or would you just leave it to the original Quartet??

[kennyboy]

Are you retarded?

[Dr. Love]

I'd leave it as it was, which was damn near immaculate.

[BrownSound1]

I think Alex is a better drummer than Bissonette. While Billy is the better bassist, he can't sing backup as well as Michael Anthony can. Leave Van Halen as they WERE, and the Yankee Rose band as they were.

[Big Troubles]

Van Halen as it were is the only Van Halen that matters. David Lee Roth's band mates after that are all fine, but not comparable to classic Van Halen. I would take a drunk, slow Eddie from 81 over Vai on his best day ever. Billy on bass is cool, but again Mike is classic and Id stick with classic shit. Alex today is garbage, no doubt. But even Al today would blow Bissonette off the stage.

[tjvhou812]

Originally posted by TMR
If you could merge the two bands of David Lee Roth, who would be in the future lineup of Van Halen.


David Lee Roth
Steve Vai
Billy Sheehan
Eddie Van Halen
Greg Bissonette

Ushers would be Alex Van Halen and Michael Anthony!!

Or would you just leave it to the original Quartet??

eddie alex mike dave

[tjvhou812]

Originally posted by Big Troubles
Van Halen as it were is the only Van Halen that matters. David Lee Roth's band mates after that are all fine, but not comparable to classic Van Halen. I would take a drunk, slow Eddie from 81 over Vai on his best day ever. Billy on bass is cool, but again Mike is classic and Id stick with classic shit. Alex today is garbage, no doubt. But even Al today would blow Bissonette off the stage.

i agree 100%

[Bill Lumbergh]

I only care if Dave and Ed are there at this point.

[PHOENIX]

Mark Stone!

[DavidLeeNatra]

Originally posted by Big Troubles
Alex today is garbage, no doubt. But even Al today would blow Bissonette off the stage.

I doubt that big times...but would leave the original line up...

[Big Troubles]

"Mark Stone!" LOL yeah. does he still play?

[dave_is_vh]

Dave and Ed are all that matter. Keep Michael because he isn't a troublemaker and has great background vocals. Dump Al cause he is a useless a*#hole. Bissnette is fine or any other decent drummer that isn't a troublemaker. Sheehan is essentially a frustrated guitar player that is full of himself. Forget him.

[bru87tr]

is this for real ?

if I have to answer the original members.

come on....

[Golden AWe]

Lee Van Cleef
Chevy Van
Van Illa Ice

[cwsmith17]

Once you mess with the original ingredients, you risk killing the recipe grasshopper!