'Van Halen Rising' Book Chat with Greg Renoff - Oct. 17th, 9pm ET

[DONNIEP]

I refuse to listen to this because I'm sure it sucks

[vandeleur]

I refuse to listen to this because I'm sure it sucks

It has piped in vocals

[DONNIEP]

Here's the Grail. And I hear Mike and I hear Ed's flat vocals. Ed's singing, sure enough. But he adds next to nothing and saying he's underrated is like saying the guy running the lights is underrated.

[vandeleur]

I fucking love that video

[DONNIEP]

I fucking love that video

Me too. But it proves my point that Ed doesn't have an "underrated" voice. At best he's a decent backing vocal singer. Or was. Now he's just a bitter old cunt with a recently unfattified ex wife that can't seem to get her kid to jump on the cheap TV-lose-weight-bandwagon.

But she retwatted a twit so that has to make it so.

[vandeleur]

It proves you cant get this stuff no more bud.

[DLR Bridge]

Opinions DP. Now get get back to cleaning your gunz.

[DONNIEP]

Blah blah blah...you guys really think Ed had an "underrated voice" then you're crazy as shit. Ed's voice is marginal at best. And always was.

VA got his retwat. Trying to prove it's true is ridiculous.

[vandeleur]

So says the man claiming the man with the swords is a cheer leader , long way to go japan just to learn the pom pom

[DLR Bridge]

Skip to 4:45 for some Ed vocals. He does ok. Again, not saying he's a great singer, but I actually like his grisly Tom Waits voice. I'd buy a solo CD with him singing before I'd get anything with Hags on it.

[DONNIEP]

Skip to 4:45 for some Ed vocals. He does ok. Again, not saying he's a great singer, but I actually like his grisly Tom Waits voice. I'd buy a solo CD with him singing before I'd get anything with Hags on it.

You are nuts and have vinegary Bawllz. Ed sucks harder than my Dyson on this track.

[vandeleur]

I couldnt listen I hate chezrone

[DONNIEP]

I couldnt listen I hate chezrone

But thays Ed's brother!! He looks more like Ed than Al, according to Big Gay Ed!

Really, you fags make it too easy.

[vandeleur]

gone fishing

[Northern Girl]

Holy shit! I've never heard that before. I had no idea. So many comments come to mind.