If given the choice...which would you prefer?

[DLR_EngineRoom]

Which would you prefer - if given the Gawd-Like choice?

* Total Roth/Halen reunion - (new CD + 'making of' DVD + World Tour)

~ OR ~

* Classic Van Halen releases (tons of classic concerts on DVD & CD with rare interviews etc. remastered)


Contestants make your selections....

[thome]

Reunion -no- doubt. The old stuff is their an will come out someday.

Roth On!

[DLR_EngineRoom]

Originally posted by thome
...the old stuff is their an will come out someday.

Roth On!

ya think?

[diamondsgirl]

I'd say a reunion if everyone could get along. It would suck if they were fueding all the time and kicking eachothers assses backstage. Ed threatening to kick Dave in the balls and stuff like that.

[stilleddiesangel]

Gee. a toughie.... I'll take box number one please!! :D

[thome]

Originally posted by DLR_EngineRoom
ya think?

I used the wrong there sorry Dude.

Jeeze I hope it comes out i was in Best Buy today looking at
Music DVDs, there was some Van Hagar thing ,Title- were so darn tough- We wear Net Stockings( Live Without a Net).
Thats it no Roth no nothing.It will be that way till thier all dead.
and Wolfie has scwanderd)sp) all his inheritance and then he will sell it
for rent money.
Thats Life as Some people say.

[Terry]

Tough one.

Would be best to put out a slamming CVH oldies box set, THEN follow that up with a new album and tour.

Put it this way: I know I want to see that CVH oldies stuff released. Am not so sure I want to see a reunion anymore; just have serious doubts those guys (well, namely Ed) can pull it off, and my fear is Roth would go for it because he knows so many want to see it even if Eddie isn't operating at 100%. Sort of the wrong execution of the right idea.

[spmusicplyr]

the reunion wouldnt be anything like VH in 84 so i'd take the set and relive the memories

[DLR_EngineRoom]

Interesting results.....it wasn't an obvious choice to me...

[Wonder Twins]

We need to see a reunion.

[saint]

Its too late

[bantonelli]

WHY THE HECK DIDN"T VAN HALEN/ROTH ERA PUT OUT A LIVE ALBUM ????? What fun that would have been to listen to....you know how Dave get the audience going with his ROTHISMS during a concert.....would have been great to hear and play and replay !!!!

[Vinnie Velvet]

Fuck, even a one-off show on Pay Per View would be awesome.

JUST DO SOMETHING!!!

[fatmanwalking]

I would take a reunion. Eddie has not slipped as much as people think. 1998 he was playing dead on Mean Street, Unchained, I'm the One, Feel your Love and even last year was doing dead on versions of I'm the One in soundcheck.

Played the intro to Hot for Teacher a few times last year as well. Roth gets him into shape as well. As much as they don't get along, they both get their best results from being around each other.

More Me Wise Magic please!!!

[thome]

keep that in mind
when we say goodbye
cuz you cant get this stuff no more

a slice at a time like a pizza pie
you serve up the truth dont
want it anymore
cuz you cant get this stuff no more

CGTSNM & MWM is all there may ever be and if so thats more than what i had.

they are perfect get together and test the water tunes.

Two tunes in twenty years You would think even ED can stomach Dave for longer than that. Yes/No ?