"Revenge of the Sith" : How was it for you?

[bueno bob]

Originally posted by Mr Grimsdale
that's just bad directing

that's kind of key to the story so those extra two lines you've suggested should have been in there

GEORGE!! CALL ME!! I'LL DIRECT THE TV SHOW!!

My references are Mr. Grimsdale. You should hire me based on that ALONE.

[Mr Grimsdale]

Originally posted by fe_lung
Maybe Ben was assuming that she wasn't strong with the force like Luke was..... You have to remember that other than those few seconds, he was never around her, so maybe he wasn't able to sense her abilities...

Er... Yoda wasn't around eithe of them at birth and yet he knew.

Christ, I'm beginning to sound like someone who takes all this seriously. Where did I put the sleeping tablets?

[Vinnie Velvet]

Originally posted by bueno bob
I've always looked at all of the Star Wars movies that way...they're great fun, if not necessarily great examples of what a movie could be...I won't argue that. Often times, the dialogue is terrible, and I can always count at least 2-3 scenes in each Star Wars movie I could have done without having to sit through, but overall...it's just play time for me...

Han Solo sucks in Jedi. You can tell Ford didn't want to do another Star Wars movie.

I still crack up at Luke's whiney "Nooooooooo" and "That's impossible!!" after Vader's revelation to him.

In fact, myself and others I know have always laughed at that scene, going back to the 80s.

[bueno bob]

Originally posted by Mr Grimsdale
Er... Yoda wasn't around eithe of them at birth and yet he knew.

Christ, I'm beginning to sound like someone who takes all this seriously. Where did I put the sleeping tablets?

lmao, that's gotta be worth a five star somewhere...

[Figs]

At least there was a Commander Cody in the movie!

Two triple cheese side order of fries-
Two triple cheese side order of fries-

[Dave's Bitch]

im going to see it one more time tomorrow.i love that film

[FasterPussycat]

it seems cold in here!

[Warham]

Why, are your nipples hard or something?

[bueno bob]

Originally posted by FasterPussycat
it seems cold in here!

Probably the frigid GUNT you have, WetterPussyflaps!

[bueno bob]

Originally posted by Warham
Why, are your nipples hard or something?

Nice GIF, War!

Where do you get such wonderful things?

[Warham]

Oh...I dunno. I rip them off of various SW forums.

Oh shit, is that a spoiler for you. LOL

[bueno bob]

Sweet...I may end up doing likewise one of these days...

Maybe even now, might be that I can find a good moving Vader avatar somewhere's...

[Warham]

I have a short clip of the final battle with Luke. It's a few seconds.

[bueno bob]

Maybe. If I don't find anything better by tomorrow, I'll hit ya up for that.

[Antman]

[

One thing I was shocked at was how Obi-Wan just left Anakin to die.

if Anakin really was like a brother to him, Obi would have picked him up, loaded him into the ship and taken him back for medical attention. He could have been reabilitated, rebuilt and hopefully turned back to the good path. After all, it was Palps who tricked and turned him; really not Anakin's fault.

Mezro...you don't just walk away from "the chosen one" if there was any chance to save him... [/B][/QUOTE]

Obi Wan had no choice. Annakin had to be stopped, after all he was now part of the Sith rule of two. When Padme said to Obi Wan "You're going to kill him, aren't you" Obi Wan did not respond. Although I do believe Annakin did not want to turn. Palpatine tricked him, promising he could save Padme. Vader's first words after he was fitted with the armor were "Where's Padme?" To which Palpatine lied "You killed her" Annakin now truly had nothing else to live for other than to make all who got in his way pay for his suffering.

I also thought the score was perfect as well, especially when the Jedi were killed one by one in battle when the clone troopers turned on them. I think it may be the best film of the six.