The problem as I see it
Dave showed when he wants to he can still sing the songs and sing them well. He was really, really good on the Kimmel show. He sang the songs in time, in a natural voice, and threw in a few screams!. The Ellen performance was not as good. Dave seemed to be straying up there, and when he goes high he sounds terrible. While I've not seen as much as most people here, most of the pre kimmel stuff I've seen Dave was not sounding so hot. The strained yelping, spitting out the lyrics in some bizarre way instead of singing the songs in time. Not pleasing to my ears, at least.
Basically, Dave has proven that he CAN still sing the songs and sing them well, but it seems he'd rather piss around with the campy jazz hands and all that crap. I get he's a showman, but with his vocal limitations as they are now I would much rather hear him sing the songs well than twirl some batons and yelp.
To say Dave has done a consistently great job since being back in Van Halen would be flat out wrong. It would also be called being a sheep.
(Look at that fryingdutchman, an opinion
)
Dave showed when he wants to he can still sing the songs and sing them well. He was really, really good on the Kimmel show. He sang the songs in time, in a natural voice, and threw in a few screams!. The Ellen performance was not as good. Dave seemed to be straying up there, and when he goes high he sounds terrible. While I've not seen as much as most people here, most of the pre kimmel stuff I've seen Dave was not sounding so hot. The strained yelping, spitting out the lyrics in some bizarre way instead of singing the songs in time. Not pleasing to my ears, at least.
Basically, Dave has proven that he CAN still sing the songs and sing them well, but it seems he'd rather piss around with the campy jazz hands and all that crap. I get he's a showman, but with his vocal limitations as they are now I would much rather hear him sing the songs well than twirl some batons and yelp.
To say Dave has done a consistently great job since being back in Van Halen would be flat out wrong. It would also be called being a sheep.
(Look at that fryingdutchman, an opinion

Comment