do not overextend Dave's contribution to VH

[pete]

Originally posted by MUSICMANN
Some of you here are on crack. Whoever thinks that bohnam and jones wasn't a great part in zeps success is just plain dumb. and that stands for al and mike also.

no doubt

[DavidLeeNatra]

Originally posted by MUSICMANN
Some of you here are on crack. Whoever thinks that bohnam and jones wasn't a great part in zeps success is just plain dumb. and that stands for al and mike also.

then answer my fucking question: why was mike not on every album???

[MUSICMANN]

vh 3 was edward's solo album that's all.

[pete]

Originally posted by dave_is_vh
Pete you must be one of those people that complain when Ace or Peter are kicked out of Kiss.

no they suck

and so does kiss at this point.

but for you to call John Paul Jones insignifigant is.... not educated.

or John Bonham. You don't have to play like neil peart to have a sound. & bonham did.

If you can't hear that.

step down.

the only band that fit your description in that list was maiden.

[DavidLeeNatra]

Originally posted by MUSICMANN
vh 3 was edward's solo album that's all.

seems you run a little bit out of arguments at this point...

[MUSICMANN]

I truly believe that the reason that mike did not play to much on the balanced album was he was getting the vibe that sammy was about to get the boot. vh3 as i mentioned.

[dave_is_vh]

What did Paul Jones write besides No Quarter. I'll admit No Quarter is a killer song.

[DavidLeeNatra]

what did mike or al write? except for their names on the albums ed and dave wrote for them?

[pete]

Originally posted by dave_is_vh
What did Paul Jones write besides No Quarter. I'll admit No Quarter is a killer song.

I cannot argue this with you.

We're in different worlds.

[MUSICMANN]

You guys are rough here. All i'm saying is that dave didn't go around saying al play this beat ed play this riff, it was a combined effort from the four. And we are talking about classic vh albums not any afterwards.

[MUSICMANN]

Al and mike bohnam and jones, they were integral parts to the bands they were in.

[Big Troubles]

Originally posted by MUSICMANN
I don't think you could look back on any of the covers they did and say it was dave who made them all the more greater. It is easy to look at gigalo and california girls and say who remembers the origanals. That was dave alone promoting dave. All the other tunes they did was vh ripping up old songs and turning them into classics.

No fucking way! That is a ridiculous statement and should have been met with an immediate dishonorable discharge from the Army! :D
To say any of the classic VH covers were rip offs is ridiculous. There might even be a shred of bullshit to one part that makes me think you were a crack baby. Make no mistake about it. Any cover VH did, Dave's voice and appeal made them that much more memorable. You Really Got Me, Pretty Woman, You're No Good and all of what was on Diver Down couldn't have sounded as good, if it weren't for the Diamond one. Picture if you can...I know it's scary, but picture Sammy singing those tunes?! Ugh! Let's remember too, because it looks like someone forgot, The Kinks version of YRGM sold far less copies than VH's re-make. What does that say?

[dave_is_vh]

Musicmann and Pete must be drummers or bassists.

[pete]

Originally posted by dave_is_vh
What did Paul Jones write besides No Quarter. I'll admit No Quarter is a killer song.

you act like a bass player and a drummer choose their instrument as a way out of not being talented. (except for RUSH)

not true.

[DavidLeeNatra]

Originally posted by MUSICMANN
All i'm saying is that dave didn't go around saying al play this beat ed play this riff

no...but he said "play it this way" and that's it...